Loved the cruise and the included tours. AMA has put a lot of thought into the tours and their organization and they are very good. Some tour guides are better than others, but you have a lot of choices and we found them to be very good overall. Food was terrific and the staff really great. Would give it 5 stars except for cabin quirks.
The cabins are tiny, even the upgraded rooms like we had. Suggestion for future ships - get rid of the outside balcony, add that space to the room and make all the windows a French balcony. I am also not sure who thought putting a window in the bathroom looking into the cabin was a good idea: even polarized, anyone using it during the night lights up the entire cabin when they turn on the light. Finally, they need better mattresses for the beds. Beds on ocean cruises are much better and I was not the only one not getting decent sleep due to the bed.