I like Avoya because I can see visually on the internet and the prices. I call the travel agent and they work with you exactly what your needs and plans are for the trip.
Holland America is a classy cruise line. If you want service, this is the ship for you. They have a fabulous library, a computer lab for workshops, America's Cooking School studio/theater to show foreign films, a piano bar, classical music presentations and lovely traditions like serving pea soup whenever the glaciers are present. They used to have a parade of waiters, cooking staff, the chefs, the dining room crew, etc. and we get to be silly and whip the napkins around.
The cruise line takes care of their people. They give them HA bags to store their purchase when they are in port or to use around to carry their items.
We hope to take up HA's upgrades on one of our trips someday.
HA's only drawback are their tours and entertainment and that is why I gave it a 9.