Great experience and all 10 in our party thoroughly enjoyed it. We have sailed on 15+ mainstream cruises in the past on NCL, HAL, RC, and Carnival and we enjoyed this way more than HAL (their cruises tend to be boring and for the much older group (aka ‘heavens waiting room’), nicer than Carnival, and similar to NCL and RC. Meals were all great and on par for a mainstream cruise line. We had an Aurea Experience aft wraparound balcony suite and enjoyed the little extra perks like anytime dining and free spa area access (and we’re not typically spa people!). Entertainment was very good and the ship and venues were all very nice with more Italian flair than most other cruise lines. The show holds over 5,600 guests and our cruise had over 4,000 but the ship rarely felt too crowded during the week. Spreading people across 19 decks does a better job than most cruises with only 12-13 decks. Issues or concerns would be with the slow embarkation (3+ hours of waiting) and our cabin was always a bit warmer than we hoped for (but others in our group had the same type of aft wraparound balcony cabin without the same issue). A $10 USB fan from Amazon did a great job to help with this. The cruise also had more international guests than most cruises leaving from the US. Typical Cruises from the US are about as diverse as a trip to Omaha, NE with 85%+ being US citizens. On this cruise, that number was likely closer to 55%. No issues for us, but if you’re not use to hearing 3 different languages being spoken in the elevator at once, it’s a different experience.
The main initial reason for booking this cruise over a NCL that also left from Miami on a comparable ship was value. Getting 3 nice suites is never cheap, but NCL’s ‘free’ offer doesn’t turn out to be a good value when you want the drink package and their cabin prices have gone way up. The gratuity on NCL was over $1,600 for 10 passengers for something ‘free’ whereas MSC had the free drink and WiFi package which was….free. Gratuity was built into the package and no additional charges. So comparing 3 NCL mini suites with drinks was $21k vs 3 MSC Aurea Experience suites (1 step down from Yacht Club top suites) was $15k. In no way did we ever feel like anything was missing from our experience to pay 40% more. I will definitely consider MSC again.