Love the freestyle cruising aspect of NCL and lack of formal nights. It's just that much less to pack and worry about. I would give any cruiseline a 7 or less right now, though. I'm sick of all the extra charges for pictures, drinks, specialty dining, yada yada yada. Many of the excursions are a waste of time and money as are all the "private islands". The private islands have no personality and are basically a joke, unless you have never seen the real Caribbean. The cruise did have great entertainment and some unique and fun activites on the upper deck (ropes course and plank as well as the water slides). I hate how many/most of the ship designs funnel you through the smokey casino areas!