The good: love all the extra- NorthStar, Sky dive, flow rider, . Bathroom additions of bar in corner (to aid shaving legs) night light (great for inside rooms). Clean and well maintained ships.
The not so good: Not have conditioner (it was a body wash & shampoo --> YUCK) - bring your own, which sucks, as even 2 and 3 star hotel provide all 3. Excursions in DR were a total mess!! Have everyone report to theatre, not organized, only 1 person handing out sticker, no one directing traffic, people late for excursion and DR excursion also not what expected. Said "working plantation." - topped at someone house. Said sugar cane field- pulled on side of field and they had sugar cane in truck open for taste testing.
Also for the tech- Northstar and sky dive and shows- if you don't book when get on ship you won't be able to do them. Many items were completed booked before even boarded ship. The boats getting so big that the ports can't handle them and frankly one reason to cruise is to SEE the PORT! :) You also used to be able to 'rate' the tours, but seems like they/RC took that away. I found nightly entertainment just OK. The Book good. but the Showgirls not great and the superhero (effectors?) one (drone part phenomenal) and rest of the show just Ok.