First and foremost - our Avoya travel agent, Julie, was excellent. Top notch service and responsiveness. Even post-cruise as she chases some cancelled excursion refunds for us - she's always been there.
The good:
• Embarking and disembarking – easy, quick, and no issues with luggage. Only 98 passengers on board so I think that helps, but we had no waits, no lines, nothing for the entire 12 nights.
• The stateroom – incredible. Horizon cabin and having the extra balcony space inside the cabin was awesome. The bathroom and shower – top tier! Cabin steward was awesome and we got into a great rhythm with him after a day or so. Water bottles were always filled and mini-fridge was always stocked.
• Dining was also excellent. Our first two nights of dining room service were a bit rocky (walked out at one point, but were roped back in by the dining manager), but we moved to Ruben for the remainder of the journey and were never disappointed. Eddison at 7Aft was also excellent as well as Sanjay at Paula’s Pantry. Dinner menus changed nightly and the overwhelming majority of the food was excellent. A few misses, but always corrected. Breakfast and lunch are buffets, but on a much smaller scale than large cruise lines. Food was consistently fresh and at the right temperature. They had some awesome soups and the live cooking station had some excellent dishes, too. Burgers at 7Aft – excellent! Dinner at 7Aft was equally impressive. Note that I was unable to come close to finishing that 35oz Tomahawk steak (that they added a lobster tail to…)! The desserts may have actually been the highlight though. On the galley tour we met the pastry chef – he does an amazing job.
• The excursions were very well-planned and excellent. Whether they were walking, via bus, or boat – always excellent guides and facilities. Most ports were tender ports and the process was extremely efficient. We did do many ports on our own though, too. With that being said – the ports of call were incredible. So many unique islands mixed in with the big stops (e.g. Rome, Florence).
• Alone time! At 50% capacity we felt like we had the ship almost to ourselves at times. We may have been the only ones using the fitness studio! The pool – virtually there alone. Dining room felt like it was just ours at times.
• Hugo’s “Tequila” performance!! The crew talent show was a highlight - that’s all I’m saying! We weren’t on this cruise for entertainment so if that’s your thing you might be disappointed. I think Atlas is fairly clear on the entertainment options, but I have seen other reviews with complaints.
• The crew! They all know your name within a day or so. Friendly and helpful – even when things went wrong.
The bad:
• Atlas shoreside operations and overall organizational issues. Pre-cruise issues with paperwork gone “missing” (seen other reviews on that)…. Credit card info “missing”… cancelled excursion refunds. There were times I was just left shaking my head in disbelief, but they always were very apologetic and worked to make things right. And that mostly had to do with the fact that they royally screwed up our anniversary celebration. Travel agent had it noted what day we were celebration, but ended up getting another note in our cabin because they stated that information was not on file. So after arranging everything through Reception – they blew it. It never happened and I was pissed – it was going to be a surprise for my wife so I didn’t even mention it to her until…. The phone rings in our stateroom around 10PM asking we “we didn’t show up in the dining room” for our celebration?! I hate when things get screwed up and they try to pin it on the customer. They asked to bring it to our stateroom right then and there and I politely declined. Sure as shit there’s knocking on our door a bit later and that only got me going more. The Reception agent ended up finding us the next day and owned his error by putting the wrong location in the system (we were at 7Aft). But it’s small ship with a handful of passengers… we had reservations for 7Aft so they could have easily found us….
• Along with that 50% capacity came cancelled excursions that were pre-booked. They also won’t refund you until after the end of the cruise. We were only partially refunded and after contacting Atlas were advised that “only your travel agent can contact Customer Relations to fix…”.
• TV & wi-fi had spotty service at times. I think the longest lines I saw the entire time were people at reception dealing with wi-fi issues! Other things that were offline – the pool for a day and the hot tubs for more than one day. The wall unit in the gym was also broke at one point.
• If onboard shopping is your thing you will be disappointed. That’s not our thing either (we did enough damage in port), but the ship store basically has limited inventory. Since the ship is in port most of the time the store is also not open due to maritime regs, etc. Wasn’t a big deal for us, but I wonder if Atlas is missing a revenue opportunity there? Note also that if you have any onboard credit that it can’t be used for merchandise.
Overall may have been rated a 5 star experience, but the issues with having to resend documents over and over, the anniversary debacle, and now chasing refunds post-cruise definitely brings the review down a notch.