I'll start by saying that this was a fabulous week. The yacht is beautiful and our stateroom was comfortable and well appointed, even though we chose the lowest category. There weren't many drawers or shelves, but hanging space and bathroom storage was ample.
We were drawn to the ports, mostly quite small and quaint, keeping us away from large cruise ships and their passengers. That said, we traveled around a national holiday in France and European tourists were everywhere, and in large numbers. That didn't detract much from the port experience. The cultural immersion in Mallorca was wonderful.
I made the mistake, though, of expected meals similar to those on Oceania and the food somehow did not compare favorably, as beautifully presented as it was. Some portions was miniscule (one small scallop as an appetizer?) and some dishes just missed the mark. Service was spotty; it was consistently difficult to get coffee in the dining room during breakfast, even though there were plenty of crew members around. Paula's Pantry, however, was a blessing.
We weren't expecting much onboard entertainment, but we were still disappointed by the scarcity. The cruise director, Julie, is a wonderful singer. It seemed odd to have a guest singer who performed in a similar style on the two nights she was featured. That choice seemed redundant to me. With only one guest performer, why not have something completely different? Having an additional onboard pianist is basic, too.
I am certainly not comparing to the big ships. We found a lot more to do and more variety in entertainment on Windstar and Oceania sailings. The guest chefs were fun but only offered one interactive event, a pizza making class. They were great, but little else encouraged passengers to interact. There was no trivia (OK, I'm a geek). I'd say that I was more surprised than disappointed at how little was happening onboard.
We often explore independently, but on this cruise we almost had no choice. There were very few excursions to choose from and they booked up quickly. I had received a message before sailing to not choose an excursion for Mallorca because of the included immersion, but that was scheduled for the evening. We would have liked the train tour during the day, but it was filled to capacity.
As others have pointed out, the "free wifi" was problematic. Ours ran out by the ed of the second day and we hardly used it. I sent out maybe 6-8 messages but was told "something must have been running in the background". My bad, I didn't turn off wifi when not in use. I have gotten by with the most basic internet packages on other cruises and have never run out.
I'd like to end positively, though. I would definitely sail with Atlas again. Overall, it really was a great experience. Next time I will know what to expect. We'll be back on Oceania and Windstar, too, probably sooner.