We don't like the a la carte pricing at all. While it might be a good deal, it requires too much analysis. We prefer an all inclusive model.
Plus, the level of noise in our room (coming from a kitchen work area), kept us up until 11:30 every night.
On the positive side, the ship was beautiful with spacious rooms. The specialty dining restaurants were stunning. That said, and despite all the hype, we did not find the food to be that great.